☰

FORHUMANRIGHTSBW.COM

Title: The Rule of Law: A Living Shield for Human Rights in Botswana and Malawi

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) asserts that "human rights should be protected by the rule of law." Yet, for millions in Southern Africa, the journey from constitutional promise to lived reality remains fraught with obstacles. For the human rights advocacy organization forhumanrightsbw, the mission is to spotlight the vital link between robust legal institutions and the protection of fundamental freedoms. This article examines the current state of human rights and the rule of law in two nations at the heart of this struggle: Botswana and Malawi.

The Rule of Law: The Bedrock of Human Rights

The rule of law is not merely a legal principle; it is the mechanism that transforms rights from abstract ideals into enforceable guarantees. As recently emphasized at the opening of the 2026 Judicial Year of the African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights, "no society can thrive where justice is compromised or institutions are weakened". Without independent courts and respect for judicial decisions, rights become "promises on paper". This foundational truth is being tested in real-time across the continent, where rising executive overreach and shrinking civic space threaten democratic gains.

Botswana: Progress Amidst Persistent Gaps

Botswana has long been touted as one of Africa’s most stable democracies. However, 2026 has been a year of both significant progress and glaring challenges.

Institutional Progress: In a landmark move, Botswana is advancing plans to establish a Constitutional Court aimed at addressing human rights concerns, tribal disputes, and land issues. This court is designed to serve as a "guardian" of the Constitution, ensuring that all citizens have recourse when their rights are violated. Public consultations have sparked robust dialogue, with legal experts emphasizing that the court will make justice more accessible and affordable. This initiative signals a strong commitment to constitutionalism and the protection of human rights.

The LGBTQ+ Rights Frontier: In a historic case, the Botswana High Court is hearing an application to decriminalize homosexuality. The applicant, represented by lawyer Gosego Lekgowe, argues that the colonial-era penal code fosters a climate of fear, limiting the ability of LGBTQ+ individuals to live openly. While the state argues that society is "not yet ready," President Mokgweetsi Masisi has publicly stated that citizens in same-sex relationships "deserve to have their rights protected". The outcome of this case will be a major test of Botswana's commitment to equality for all.

Justice Delayed: The Case of Retshepile Setso Tshedu: The tragic death of 13-year-old Retshepile Setso Tshedu has exposed a devastating failure in Botswana's child protection and justice systems. Her death, initially reported as a suicide, was later found to involve sexual abuse. Despite the gravity of the evidence, no arrests have been made ten months after her death, prompting an online petition with over 62,000 signatures demanding justice. This case underscores the urgent need for systemic reforms, including independent oversight of policing and stronger support for survivors of gender-based violence. As the petition states, "When a child can be abused, silenced and justice delayed without consequence, it signals a failure of the systems meant to protect the most vulnerable".

Malawi: A Crisis of Impunity

Malawi has ratified key international human rights covenants, but a gaping chasm exists between these commitments and the lived reality for many of its citizens. A Human Rights Watch report from March 2026 urges Malawi to address persistent human rights gaps, including the criminalization of same-sex relations and the failure to decriminalize abortion in cases of rape or risk to the mother's life.

The Witchcraft Killings Epidemic: Perhaps the most harrowing human rights crisis in Malawi is the surge in killings of elderly people accused of witchcraft. In the first four months of 2026 alone, 11 elderly people have been brutally killed. More than 300 elderly Malawians have been killed on witchcraft charges since 2015. The crisis is exacerbated by institutional failure: the colonial-era Witchcraft Act of 1911 is rarely enforced, and law enforcement officials themselves often hold witchcraft beliefs, creating a culture of impunity. The Malawi Network of Older Persons Organisations warns that the country is "sitting on a ticking time bomb".

The Role of Advocates: Despite these challenges, dedicated advocates are fighting for change. Organizations like the Southern Africa Litigation Centre (SALC) and Justice Advocacy Africa (JAA) are working to strengthen the rule of law. JAA has trained over 3,000 lawyers across Malawi, Botswana, Uganda, and Kenya, emphasizing pro bono services for underserved communities. Their work is critical in building a legal culture that prioritizes human rights.

A Call to Action

The stories from Botswana and Malawi reveal a common thread: the rule of law is the indispensable shield for human rights. Where it is strong, rights can be vindicated. Where it is weak, as in the cases of a murdered child in Botswana or elderly victims of witchcraft in Malawi, impunity reigns.

For forhumanrightsbw.com, the path forward is clear. We must advocate for:

  1. Strengthening Judicial Independence: Courts must be free from political interference.

  2. Ensuring Accountability: No perpetrator, regardless of status, should be above the law.

  3. Empowering Civil Society: Grassroots organizations and legal advocates need resources and protection.

  4. Closing the Implementation Gap: Laws on paper must be enforced in practice.

As President John Dramani Mahama declared, "No individual and no institution should stand above the law". The fight for human rights is a fight for the rule of law. It is a fight for justice, for accountability, and for the dignity of every person in Botswana, Malawi, and across Africa. The time to act is now.